Put the same carrots, apple and ginger through a juicer and a blender, and you end up with two very different drinks. One is clear, bright and quick to drink; the other is thick, filling and slower. Both look like health in a glass, and both can be. But the body treats them differently, and knowing why lets you choose the right one for the right moment.
What a juicer takes away
A juicer separates the liquid from the pulp. The water, natural sugars, most of the vitamin C, potassium and many water-soluble plant compounds go into the glass. Most of the insoluble fibre, the cell walls and the skins go into the bin. That pulp is more than roughage. A large share of the polyphenols in fruit and vegetables are bound to fibre; they travel down to the large intestine, where gut bacteria slowly release them and turn them into compounds the body can use.1 Throw away the pulp and you throw away much of that slow-release treasure, along with food for the gut microbes themselves. (See The Master Regulator.)
Fibre is also what slows sugar down. In a classic study, volunteers ate apples whole, as a purée, or as juice. The juice was drunk far faster, filled people least, raised insulin most, and was followed by a dip in blood sugar below where it started: the kind of drop that sends you looking for the biscuit tin.2 A later study found that a whole apple eaten before lunch reduced how much people ate at the meal, purée less so, and juice hardly at all.3 Calories taken as liquid simply don't register with the appetite the way chewed food does.4
The long view matches. Following more than 187,000 American health professionals for up to 24 years, Muraki and colleagues found that people who ate more whole fruit, blueberries, grapes and apples especially, had a lower risk of type 2 diabetes, while those who drank more fruit juice had a higher one. Swapping juice for the same amount of whole fruit was linked with lower risk.5 UK nutrition advisers now count the sugar in fruit juice, and in blended fruit, as "free sugar", alongside sugar added to food.6 (See Balancing the Sugar Seesaw.)
What a blender keeps
A blender keeps everything: skin, pulp, fibre and the polyphenols bound to it. The fibre is cut into smaller pieces, so a smoothie is a little less filling than the whole food you would chew, but far more filling than juice. Blending can even help: when fruit was blended with its seeds and skins in a high-powered blender, the rise in blood sugar was smaller than from fruit juice.7 The fat-soluble nutrients in carrots, kale and mango, such as beta-carotene and lutein, are absorbed much better when a little fat travels with them,8 which is easy to add to a smoothie and impossible to add to the pulp you threw away.
Centrifugal or cold-press?
Centrifugal juicers spin fast, shredding produce against a blade; they are quick, but they whip air into the juice and warm it a little, so it separates and loses its freshness sooner. Cold-press (slow or masticating) juicers crush and press, giving more juice from leafy greens and a drink that keeps its colour and taste a little longer. The honest truth is that the differences in nutrients are modest. What matters far more is what goes in, and drinking it fresh, ideally within the hour.
Juice is a tonic. A smoothie is a meal.
When a juice is the better choice
- Convalescence and poor appetite. After illness or surgery, or when eating feels like hard work, a fresh vegetable juice delivers minerals, vitamins and plant compounds without asking much of the body. Pair it with protein from soups, broths, eggs or yoghurt as appetite returns.
- Very sensitive digestion. When the gut is raw and reactive, a low-fibre juice can be easier than a fibre-heavy smoothie for a while.
- A concentrated hit of vegetables. A glass of juice can hold more vegetables than most people would eat in a sitting, a real gift on the way to 30 plants a week.
- Beetroot for exercise. Beetroot is rich in nitrate, which the body turns into nitric oxide, a molecule that widens blood vessels and makes muscles use oxygen more efficiently. In trials, a few days of beetroot juice lowered the oxygen cost of exercise and let people keep going at hard effort for longer.9 Over four weeks, daily beetroot juice also lowered blood pressure in people with raised pressure.10 Remarkably, the first step happens in your mouth: bacteria on the tongue convert nitrate to nitrite, and antiseptic mouthwash largely blocks the effect.11 If you take blood pressure medicines, check with your GP or pharmacist before drinking it regularly.
When a smoothie is the better choice
- Breakfast, when you need something to carry you to lunch.
- Fullness, if you are trying to eat less without feeling hungry.
- Blood sugar, if you have energy dips, cravings, insulin resistance or diabetes.
- Building a complete meal, because protein and fat can go in the same glass.
The Rootwise rules for both
- Lead with vegetables. Mostly vegetables, a little fruit for flavour: cucumber, celery, fennel, kale, carrot and beetroot, with apple, pear, citrus or kiwi as the accent rather than the base.
- Add protein and fat to smoothies. Live yoghurt or kefir, hemp seeds, ground linseed, pumpkin seeds, Brazil nuts, almond butter or avocado turn a sweet drink into a steady one.
- Drink juice with or alongside a meal, not on an empty stomach in place of one, so its sugars arrive with food to slow them.
- Sip, don't gulp. Taking your time lets the gut's fullness signals catch up.
- Rotate your greens. Spinach, chard and beet greens are very high in oxalate. Doctors have reported kidney damage from oxalate crystals in people drinking large amounts of green juice daily during "cleanses".12,13 Choose kale, cucumber, celery, romaine and pak choi for everyday glasses, and keep spinach for cooked dishes. (See Hidden in the Greens.)
- Look after your teeth. Juice and fruit smoothies are acidic and sugary. Drink them in one sitting rather than sipping all morning, then rinse your mouth with water, and wait an hour before brushing so softened enamel can harden again.14
Three from the Rootwise kitchen
Energy Lift (juice): juice beetroot, carrot, apple, lemon and a thumb of ginger. Earthy, sweet and sharp, and a lovely glass a couple of hours before exercise.
Nutrient Boost (smoothie): blend kale, avocado, kiwi, cucumber, lime and ginger with live yoghurt or kefir (or hemp seeds for dairy-free) and ground linseed. Green, creamy and filling.
Gut Soother (smoothie): blend ripe pear and oats with kefir, ground linseed, cinnamon, cardamom and fresh ginger. Gentle, warming and soothing for a tender gut.
Other favourites include Golden Citrus (carrot, orange, lemon, ginger and turmeric), Green Refresher (cucumber, celery, fennel, apple, lemon, mint and broccoli sprouts) and Skin Glow (mango, carrot, orange, kefir, pumpkin seeds, Brazil nuts and turmeric).
Juice "cleanses", honestly
Your liver and kidneys do the cleansing, every minute of every day, and no juice does it for them.15 What food can do is supply the raw materials they work with. Broccoli sprouts are a beautiful example: they are an exceptionally rich source of the compound that becomes sulphoraphane,16 which switches on the body's own clearing enzymes. In a twelve-week trial in a heavily polluted region of China, a daily broccoli sprout drink increased the amount of benzene, a traffic pollutant, that people cleared in their urine by 61%.17 That is the real job food does: supplying the organs that already do the work. A few days built around vegetable juices, smoothies, soups and simple whole food can be a lovely reset, but juice alone for days on end means little protein, blood sugar swings and, with spinach-heavy recipes, a real oxalate load.
Buying juice and smoothies
Most shop-bought juices and smoothies are pasteurised by heat, or pressure-treated, to make them safe and give them a longer shelf life, which reduces vitamin C and some delicate plant compounds. Read the label: many "green" smoothies are mostly apple or grape juice, with a token handful of spinach, and a single bottle can hold more sugar than a can of fizzy drink. Look for vegetables at the top of the ingredients list. Unpasteurised juice from a juice bar is fresher but carries a small food-safety risk, so it is best avoided in pregnancy, by older adults and by anyone with lowered immunity.
In short
- Juicing removes most insoluble fibre and the polyphenols bound to it; blending keeps them.
- Juice is absorbed quickly, fills you least and is linked with higher type 2 diabetes risk when it replaces whole fruit; smoothies are steadier and more filling.
- Juice suits convalescence, poor appetite, very sensitive digestion, a concentrated vegetable boost and beetroot before exercise.
- Smoothies suit breakfast, fullness and blood sugar, especially with protein and fat added.
- Lead with vegetables, rotate your greens, drink with food, rinse with water afterwards, and let your liver and kidneys do the cleansing, well supplied.
At Rootwise, we love a glass of something fresh and bright, and we want it to work for you. If you'd like to know whether juices, smoothies or neither suit your digestion, your blood sugar and your energy right now, a Rootwise consultation looks at the whole picture and helps you find what truly nourishes you.
References
- Saura-Calixto F. Dietary fiber as a carrier of dietary antioxidants: an essential physiological function. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2011.
- Haber GB et al. Depletion and disruption of dietary fibre: effects on satiety, plasma-glucose, and serum-insulin. The Lancet, 1977.
- Flood-Obbagy JE, Rolls BJ. The effect of fruit in different forms on energy intake and satiety at a meal. Appetite, 2009.
- DiMeglio DP, Mattes RD. Liquid versus solid carbohydrate: effects on food intake and body weight. International Journal of Obesity, 2000.
- Muraki I et al. Fruit consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes: results from three prospective longitudinal cohort studies. BMJ, 2013.
- Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition. Carbohydrates and Health. London: The Stationery Office, 2015.
- Redfern KM et al. Nutrient-extraction blender preparation reduces postprandial glucose responses from fruit juice consumption. Nutrition and Diabetes, 2017.
- Brown MJ et al. Carotenoid bioavailability is higher from salads ingested with full-fat than with fat-reduced salad dressings, as measured with electrochemical detection. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2004.
- Bailey SJ et al. Dietary nitrate supplementation reduces the O2 cost of low-intensity exercise and enhances tolerance to high-intensity exercise in humans. Journal of Applied Physiology, 2009.
- Kapil V et al. Dietary nitrate provides sustained blood pressure lowering in hypertensive patients: a randomized, phase 2, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Hypertension, 2015.
- Govoni M et al. The increase in plasma nitrite after a dietary nitrate load is markedly attenuated by an antibacterial mouthwash. Nitric Oxide, 2008.
- Getting JE et al. Oxalate nephropathy due to 'juicing': case report and review. American Journal of Medicine, 2013.
- Makkapati S et al. "Green smoothie cleanse" causing acute oxalate nephropathy. American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2018.
- Salas MMS et al. Diet influenced tooth erosion prevalence in children and adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Dentistry, 2015.
- Klein AV, Kiat H. Detox diets for toxin elimination and weight management: a critical review of the evidence. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics, 2015.
- Fahey JW, Zhang Y, Talalay P. Broccoli sprouts: an exceptionally rich source of inducers of enzymes that protect against chemical carcinogens. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 1997.
- Egner PA et al. Rapid and sustainable detoxication of airborne pollutants by broccoli sprout beverage: results of a randomized clinical trial in China. Cancer Prevention Research, 2014.
This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for personal advice. If you take prescribed medicines, or have kidney disease or diabetes, check any changes to your diet, herbs or supplements with your GP or pharmacist.