← All articles Nutrition

Hidden in the Greens

Oxalates, phytates and the art of preparing plants well

11 minute read

Picture the healthiest breakfast you can imagine: a green smoothie packed with spinach, a spoon of almond butter, a sprinkle of cacao, a dash of turmeric. Then a lunch of chard and beetroot salad, almond-flour crackers, a glass of almond milk. Every one of those foods is rich in goodness. Every one is also high in oxalate, a natural plant compound that, in large amounts, the body can struggle to clear. It is one of nutrition's quiet paradoxes: the people working hardest to eat well can be the ones most at risk of overload.

What is oxalate?

Oxalate (oxalic acid) is made by plants as a defence and a store for calcium. Its sharp, tart taste is the one you notice in rhubarb and sorrel, and the faint chalky film spinach leaves on your teeth is oxalate binding calcium in your mouth. Our own liver also makes a small amount every day. Normally, most of the oxalate we eat stays bound to calcium in the gut and leaves the body in the stool; the rest is absorbed, filtered by the kidneys and passed in the urine.

The trouble starts when more is absorbed than the kidneys can comfortably handle. Oxalate combines readily with calcium to form tiny, sharp crystals. In the kidneys, these crystals are the raw material of the most common kind of kidney stone: around four in every five stones are made of calcium oxalate.1

Why plant-rich eaters are more at risk

Traditional diets spread oxalate thinly across a varied plate. Modern "superfood" eating can concentrate it. A blender makes it easy to drink in a few minutes the spinach you could never eat in a sitting, and raw spinach is one of the richest sources of oxalate of any food. Several modern health foods add to the load at once:

  • Very high: spinach, chard, beet greens, rhubarb, sorrel, almonds and almond flour, cacao and dark chocolate, buckwheat.
  • High: beetroot, cashews, sweet potato, black tea, and turmeric used generously as a supplement rather than a spice.

This is not just theory. Doctors have reported kidney failure caused by oxalate crystals in people who drank large amounts of green juice or green smoothies every day for weeks, during "cleanses" meant to make them healthier.2,3 These cases are rare, but they show how much a well-meaning habit can add up.

The gut connection

Whether oxalate becomes a problem depends as much on your gut as on your plate. A gut bacterium called Oxalobacter formigenes lives on oxalate alone, breaking it down before it can be absorbed. People who carry it have around 70% lower risk of recurring kidney stones,4 yet courses of antibiotics can wipe it out, and it doesn't always come back. Other friendly bacteria, including several lactobacilli and bifidobacteria, also break oxalate down. (See The Master Regulator.)

Poor fat absorption raises the risk too. When fat isn't absorbed well, it binds the calcium in the gut, leaving oxalate free to slip into the bloodstream. This "enteric hyperoxaluria" is well known after weight-loss surgery and in Crohn's disease, coeliac disease and pancreatic problems.5 A leaky, inflamed gut lining lets more through as well. (See You Are What You Absorb.)

Other factors tip the balance: not drinking enough water, a salty diet, sugary drinks, a low-calcium diet, low vitamin B6 (which the liver needs to avoid making extra oxalate) and high-dose vitamin C (ascorbic acid) supplements, which the body partly turns into oxalate. In a Swedish study of more than 23,000 men, those taking vitamin C supplements had about twice the risk of kidney stones.6 Vitamin C from food is a different matter, and isn't linked with stones.

The dose, the pairing and the preparation make all the difference.

Signs of oxalate overload

The clearest sign is a kidney stone, or gritty, cloudy or burning urine. Beyond the kidneys, practitioners see a pattern in clients who eat large amounts of high-oxalate foods, and it often eases when intake is brought down gently:

  • aching or stiff joints and muscles without an obvious cause
  • bladder irritation, burning or frequent urination
  • vulval pain or burning
  • digestive discomfort and loose stools
  • tiredness and poor sleep

Each of these signs has many possible causes, so they are worth looking into as a whole rather than putting down to oxalate alone. A urine test can show how much oxalate your body is clearing, and a Rootwise consultation can look at your diet, digestion and history together; your practitioner will suggest a GP visit if anything needs checking further.

Don't wait with these

Severe pain in the side or back that comes in waves, blood in the urine, or pain with a fever needs an urgent medical check.

How to bring oxalate back into balance

  • Pair it with calcium. Eating calcium-rich foods in the same meal binds oxalate in the gut so it leaves the body instead of being absorbed. A yoghurt dressing on a chard salad, or kefir in a smoothie, does real work. Cutting calcium backfires: in a five-year trial, men with stones who ate a normal-calcium diet, lower in salt and animal protein, had half the recurrences of those on a low-calcium diet.7
  • Poach, then drain. Oxalate dissolves into cooking water. Cooking high-oxalate greens in water and pouring the water away removed between a third and almost nine-tenths of their soluble oxalate in laboratory tests; steaming removed less.8
  • Rotate your greens. Kale, pak choi, rocket, watercress, cabbage, lettuce, broccoli and cauliflower are all low in oxalate and generous with nutrients. The calcium in kale is absorbed at least as well as the calcium in milk.9 Save spinach and chard for cooked dishes, a few times a week.
  • Swap the flour and the milk. Use oat, chickpea or coconut flour for some of your almond flour, and oat, hemp or coconut milk for some of your almond milk. Pumpkin seeds, hemp seeds, macadamias and coconut are lower in oxalate than almonds and cashews.
  • Drink plenty of water, enough to keep your urine pale, all day long. A squeeze of lemon adds citrate, which helps stop crystals forming.
  • Feed the gut. Live yoghurt, kefir and naturally fermented vegetables support the bacteria that break oxalate down, and a varied, fibre-rich diet keeps the gut lining strong.
  • Eat for vitamin B6: fish, poultry, eggs, pistachios, sunflower seeds, bananas and chickpeas.
  • Go gently. If you have eaten a very high-oxalate diet for a long time, bring it down gradually over a few weeks rather than all at once. Clients who cut it out overnight often report a flare of their symptoms before things settle.

This is not about fearing spinach. It is about variety, sensible portions and the kind of preparation that kitchens around the world have used for generations.

Phytates, lectins and friends

Oxalate isn't the only plant compound that asks to be handled with care. Plants can't run from what eats them, so they protect their seeds and leaves with a whole chemistry set. Some of these compounds have been called "antinutrients", but the name sells them short: most bring benefits of their own, and traditional cooking has always known how to tame them.

  • Phytates are the storage form of phosphorus in grains, beans, nuts and seeds. They bind iron, zinc and calcium and make them harder to absorb, which matters most for people who eat little meat or fish. Soaking, sprouting and fermenting wake enzymes that break phytate down, and true sourdough fermentation removes far more than ordinary yeast does.10 Yet phytate is also a powerful antioxidant, and, wonderfully, it helps prevent kidney stones: in a study of more than 96,000 women, those who ate the most phytate had about a third lower risk.11 Prepare it well rather than avoid it.
  • Lectins are proteins found in beans, lentils and grains. Raw or undercooked red kidney beans contain enough of one lectin to cause severe sickness, which is why dried beans need soaking and then a hard boil for at least ten minutes before simmering; slow cookers alone don't get hot enough.12 Properly cooked, beans are among the best-studied foods for a long, healthy life.
  • Goitrogens in raw cabbage, kale, broccoli and other brassicas can slow the thyroid's use of iodine, but only when eaten raw in very large amounts by people who are short of iodine. Cooking reduces them, and the same family gives us sulphoraphane, one of the most protective plant compounds we know. Enjoy brassicas often, mostly cooked, and include iodine-rich foods such as fish, eggs and seaweed.
  • Tannins in tea and coffee bind iron from plant foods. If your iron runs low, drink them an hour away from meals, and add vitamin C-rich foods such as peppers, citrus or parsley to the plate to help iron absorption.
  • Saponins give quinoa its bitter, soapy coating. A good rinse in a sieve before cooking washes them away.

In short

  • Oxalate is a natural plant compound; in excess, it forms crystals, most famously calcium oxalate kidney stones.
  • Plant-rich "superfood" diets, especially daily spinach smoothies, almond flour and nut milks, can concentrate it.
  • Antibiotics, poor fat absorption, low water intake, low calcium and high-dose vitamin C supplements all raise the risk.
  • Pair high-oxalate foods with calcium, boil and drain high-oxalate greens, rotate low-oxalate greens, drink well and look after the gut.
  • Phytates, lectins, goitrogens and tannins all bring benefits too; soaking, sprouting, fermenting and good cooking keep the goodness and lower the burden.

At Rootwise, we believe plants are among our greatest medicines, and that preparing them well is part of the medicine. If you suspect oxalate is part of your picture, we'll look at your whole diet, your digestion and your body's signals together, and help you build a plate that suits you.

References

  1. Khan SR et al. Kidney stones. Nature Reviews Disease Primers, 2016.
  2. Getting JE et al. Oxalate nephropathy due to 'juicing': case report and review. American Journal of Medicine, 2013.
  3. Makkapati S et al. "Green smoothie cleanse" causing acute oxalate nephropathy. American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2018.
  4. Kaufman DW et al. Oxalobacter formigenes may reduce the risk of calcium oxalate kidney stones. Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 2008.
  5. Witting C et al. Pathophysiology and treatment of enteric hyperoxaluria. Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 2021.
  6. Thomas LD et al. Ascorbic acid supplements and kidney stone incidence among men: a prospective study. JAMA Internal Medicine, 2013.
  7. Borghi L et al. Comparison of two diets for the prevention of recurrent stones in idiopathic hypercalciuria. New England Journal of Medicine, 2002.
  8. Chai W, Liebman M. Effect of different cooking methods on vegetable oxalate content. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2005.
  9. Heaney RP, Weaver CM. Calcium absorption from kale. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1990.
  10. Leenhardt F et al. Moderate decrease of pH by sourdough fermentation is sufficient to reduce phytate content of whole wheat flour through endogenous phytase activity. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2005.
  11. Curhan GC et al. Dietary factors and the risk of incident kidney stones in younger women: Nurses' Health Study II. Archives of Internal Medicine, 2004.
  12. Food Standards Agency. Pulses: how to prepare dried kidney beans safely.

This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for personal advice. If you take prescribed medicines, or have kidney disease, check any changes to your diet, herbs or supplements with your GP or pharmacist.

Plants, prepared well

A personal look at your diet, your digestion and your body's signals, so the foods you love give you everything they promise.