← All recipes Ferment

Homemade Live Yoghurt

Thick, creamy live yoghurt made with cow's or goat's milk and a reusable heirloom culture, for a fraction of the price of shop-bought.

Makes 1 litre20 minutes, plus 8–12 hours to setGluten-freeKetoRich in calcium and protein

Ingredients

  • 1 litre whole milk: organic cow's or goat's milk
  • 1 sachet heirloom yoghurt starter, or 2 tbsp plain live yoghurt from your last batch (or a good shop-bought live yoghurt to begin)

Where to get a yoghurt starter

Method

  1. Heat: gently heat the milk in a heavy pan to about 85°C, just below a simmer, stirring now and then. Hold it there for a few minutes; this gives a thicker, creamier yoghurt.
  2. Cool: take off the heat and let it cool to about 43–45°C, warm but comfortable on a clean fingertip for 10 seconds. A thermometer makes this easy.
  3. Add the culture: whisk the starter or yoghurt with a ladle of the warm milk, then stir it back into the pan.
  4. Keep warm: pour into a clean jar or wide-necked flask and keep it at about 40–45°C for 8–12 hours: in a yoghurt maker, a wide-necked vacuum flask, or an oven with just the light on, wrapped in a towel. Don't stir or move it while it sets.
  5. Chill: once set and pleasantly tangy, chill for a few hours. It keeps for about a week in the fridge.
  6. Keep some back: save 2 tbsp in a small clean jar to start your next batch within 7 days.
Allergens: contains milk. Always check the labels of shop-bought ingredients.Common sensitivities: lactose. Notice how you feel after eating them.

Why it's good for you: Homemade yoghurt is fresh, alive and free of the thickeners, sweeteners and added sugar found in many shop-bought pots, and it typically holds far more live bacteria. Longer setting times (up to 24 hours) give a tangier yoghurt with even less lactose. Yoghurt is a wonderful source of calcium and protein, and fermented dairy is linked with better gut health and blood sugar balance. Read more in The Dairy Question.

Good to know: Goat's milk makes a softer, more pourable yoghurt; strain it through muslin for an hour or two if you like it thicker. Each reused batch may set a little differently; if it becomes thin or slow, start again with fresh starter. Dairy and lactose: fermentation lowers the lactose in milk, as the bacteria feed on it, so yoghurt contains noticeably less than the milk it's made from (more the longer it ferments), and its live cultures help digest the rest, which is why many people with lactose intolerance manage it well. Fermenting doesn't remove milk proteins, so it isn't suitable for a cow's milk protein intolerance or allergy: try goat's or sheep's milk if you're intolerant (not if allergic). Plant milks contain no lactose for the cultures to feed on, so they won't ferment or set properly on their own (soya milk is a partial exception); for dairy-free live ferments, try Sparkling Water Kefir, Homemade Kombucha, Homemade Sauerkraut or Homemade Kimchi. Make it yours: Use goat's or sheep's milk; strain for Greek-style thickness, or longer for Homemade Labneh.

Food is one part of the whole picture

Read the thinking behind these recipes, or get a plan made just for you.