In the spring of 1849, Charles Darwin was in a bad way: exhausted, dizzy and constantly sick. So he took his family to Malvern and put himself in the hands of Dr James Gully and the cold water cure. Three months later, he wrote of its "astonishingly renovating action" on his health, adding that he'd thought the whole thing quackery a year before.1 Today the same idea comes with a phone app, a very costly tub and a great deal of shouting. So what can we honestly say about cold water?
An old cure in a new swimsuit
Cold water is one of the founding treatments of naturopathy. The Bavarian priest Sebastian Kneipp took to bathing in the icy Danube as a young student with tuberculosis, and credited the water with his recovery. He went on to treat people at Wörishofen for four decades, with a method resting on water, exercise, nutrition, herbs and the balance of mind and body.2 One of his patients, Benedict Lust, sailed to America in 1892 as his representative and became known as the father of naturopathy there. So this is no passing fad: it's closer to our family history.
Kneipp is also worth remembering for what he learned. He moved away from shocking the body towards gentler applications, such as cold arm baths and treading through cold water. The wheelie bin full of ice would have surprised him.
What the cold does to you
Here's the number you'll see everywhere online. In a Czech laboratory, young men sat up to their necks in water at 14°C. Noradrenaline in their blood rose by 530%, dopamine by 250%, and their metabolic rate by 350%. Cortisol, the famous stress hormone, tended to fall.3
Those are remarkable figures, and they explain the alert, lit-up feeling that swimmers describe so well. But the detail tends to get lost: those men stayed in for a full hour. That's a laboratory experiment, not a morning routine, and the figures can't be applied to a two-minute dip.
Thirty seconds did as much as ninety.
What the research shows
- Sick days. In the best-known trial, over 3,000 Dutch adults ended their usual hot shower with 30, 60 or 90 seconds of cold. They took 29% fewer sick days than the comparison group, yet had just as many days of feeling ill. The authors suggest that the illness may have felt less severe, not shorter. Thirty seconds did as well as ninety, and most wanted to carry on afterwards.4
- Inflammation and immunity. This is the study that drops jaws. Twelve healthy volunteers trained for ten days in meditation, breathing exercises and cold exposure. Then they and an untrained group were injected with a bacterial toxin. The trained group released far more adrenaline, showed a calmer inflammatory response and had fewer flu-like symptoms, which challenges the old idea that we can't influence these systems at will.5 A later trial looked at the parts separately. Cold training alone did little, the breathing did most of the work, and the two together were strongest.6
- Stress and sleep. A 2025 review of 11 trials found lower stress 12 hours after cold exposure, along with better sleep quality and quality of life. Inflammation markers rose briefly straight afterwards, an expected response to a stressor.7
- Mood. That review didn't find a change in mood across its trials, yet that's the very thing swimmers report most. A British brain imaging study found that five minutes in cold water left people feeling more alert, active and inspired, and less distressed and nervous, with matching changes in how brain networks linked up.8 A published case report describes a young woman whose long-standing depression lifted during a programme of weekly open water swims.9 Please never stop or change a prescribed medicine without your prescriber.
- Women's health. In a survey of 1,114 women who swim in cold water, those in perimenopause reported improvements in anxiety (46.9%), mood swings (34.5%), low mood (31.1%) and hot flushes (30.3%). It tells us what regular swimmers experience, and they often named the companionship as part of the benefit.10
- Infections. One study cited in a major review found 40% fewer upper respiratory infections in winter swimmers than in a comparison group.11
- Kneipp's methods. A review of 20 trials found benefits in 46 of 132 comparisons, including for circulation in the legs, menopausal symptoms, emotional wellbeing and sick days, and no difference in 81.12
- If you lift weights. Here's a surprise for the gym crowd. Men who took a ten-minute cold bath after each strength session for 12 weeks gained less strength and muscle than those who did a gentle cool-down instead.13 If building muscle is your aim, keep the cold away from your training sessions. There's more on this in The Natural Edge.
What a study can't measure
A sea swim isn't just cold. It's also daylight, salt air, movement, a horizon, friends shouting at you to get in, and a shared flask on the shingle afterwards. Take the temperature on its own in a laboratory and you've measured one thread of something much larger. That may be part of why the swimmer's experience and the trial results don't always match. An ice tub on the patio may give you the cold, but not all of the rest.
Does it suit you?
This is the question the internet never asks. In naturopathic thinking, cold water is a stimulus: it asks your body for a response, and your body has to have one to give. Someone robust and warm-blooded may come out glowing. Someone who always feels the cold, or who is depleted, burnt out and sleeping badly, may simply be adding another alarm to a system already ringing with them. We'd always want to calm the nervous system first, and to consider your constitution before choosing a treatment. Your body's answer matters too. Feeling warm, bright and energised afterwards is a good sign. Feeling chilled for hours and wiped out is telling you something else.
Safety
Cold water deserves real respect, because the risks are out of proportion to how harmless it looks.
- The first gasp. Sudden immersion below 15°C, which describes UK waters for much of the year, triggers an involuntary gasp and rapid breathing. In open water, that can mean breathing in water. It passes in about a minute. If you ever get into trouble, the RNLI's advice is to float on your back until it does.14
- Your heart. Cold water can trigger irregular heartbeats, even in healthy volunteers. Researchers believe that a clash between two opposing nervous system reflexes may explain deaths once put down to drowning or hypothermia.15 If you have a heart condition or high blood pressure, or you've ever fainted without a clear cause, please seek further advice first.
- Getting out. You keep cooling after you leave the water.11 Get dry and into warm layers straight away, and stay away from the car keys until you've properly warmed up.
- Other reasons to take advice. Please seek further advice first if you're pregnant, if you have Raynaud's or a cold allergy, or if you've been unwell.
There's good news, too: your body learns. The cold shock response eases after about four immersions.16 That's a good reason to start gently and build up with company, and never to swim alone or after a drink.
How to begin
Start with your own shower. Finish your usual warm one with a short burst of cold, breathing slowly and steadily. Kneipp's gentler methods, such as running cold water over your arms or treading through a cold stream, are a kind place to start too. If you'd like to swim, join a local group with people who know the water, go in slowly and get out while you still feel good. It costs next to nothing, and you don't need an expensive tub to feel the benefit.
Worth it or not? Our verdict
- Worth trying, for most healthy adults, as a cold finish to your shower. It's free, and 30 seconds did as well as 90 in the big trial.
- A long-standing naturopathic treatment, and much loved by people who do it.
- Sea and lake swimming may offer the most, because it brings nature and company as well as cold, but it needs real care.
- Not for everyone. Heart conditions call for advice first, and people who are depleted may do better building up their strength before adding a stimulus.
- Skip the costly tub, unless you truly want one and will use it. And keep it away from your weight training.
At Rootwise, we value cold water for what it's always been: a simple stimulus, used thoughtfully, to invite a response from the body. If you'd like to know whether it belongs in your plan, and what else might, a consultation is a good place to begin.
References
- Darwin CR. Letter to J. F. W. Herschel, 13 June 1849. Darwin Correspondence Project, letter no. 1246.
- Ko Y. Sebastian Kneipp and the Natural Cure Movement of Germany: between naturalism and modern medicine. Uisahak, 2016.
- Šrámek P et al. Human physiological responses to immersion into water of different temperatures. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2000.
- Buijze GA et al. The effect of cold showering on health and work: a randomized controlled trial. PLoS One, 2016.
- Kox M et al. Voluntary activation of the sympathetic nervous system and attenuation of the innate immune response in humans. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2014.
- Zwaag J et al. The effects of cold exposure training and a breathing exercise on the inflammatory response in humans: a pilot study. Psychosomatic Medicine, 2022.
- Cain T et al. Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One, 2025.
- Yankouskaya A et al. Short-term head-out whole-body cold-water immersion facilitates positive affect and increases interaction between large-scale brain networks. Biology, 2023.
- van Tulleken C et al. Open water swimming as a treatment for major depressive disorder. BMJ Case Reports, 2018.
- Pound M et al. How do women feel cold water swimming affects their menstrual and perimenopausal symptoms? Post Reproductive Health, 2024.
- Knechtle B et al. Cold water swimming: benefits and risks: a narrative review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2020.
- Ortiz M et al. Clinical effects of Kneipp hydrotherapy: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials. BMJ Open, 2023.
- Roberts LA et al. Post-exercise cold water immersion attenuates acute anabolic signalling and long-term adaptations in muscle to strength training. Journal of Physiology, 2015.
- Royal National Lifeboat Institution. Float to Live water safety advice, rnli.org; Met Office. Cold water shock: what it is and how to stay safe, 2025.
- Shattock MJ, Tipton MJ. "Autonomic conflict": a different way to die during cold water immersion? Journal of Physiology, 2012.
- Barwood MJ et al. Habituation of the cold shock response: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Thermal Biology, 2024.
This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for personal advice. If you take prescribed medicines, check any herbs or supplements with your GP or pharmacist, and never stop or change a prescribed medicine without your prescriber.