← All articles Gut

Same Meal, Different Medicine

Why your gut microbes decide what your food does for you

8 minute read

Sit two people down to the same bowl of walnuts and pomegranate, and they will not get the same thing from it. One may turn it into a compound that reaches the bloodstream and acts on cells throughout the body. The other may pass much of it straight through. The difference lies in the trillions of microbes in the gut, which carry out chemistry our own cells cannot. In a very real sense, food is only half the story: the other half is who is there to receive it.

Two people, one breakfast

For decades, nutrition science has worked with averages: this food has this effect. Then researchers began to measure individual people, meal by meal. In 2015, a team at Israel's Weizmann Institute tracked the blood sugar of 800 people for a week across 46,898 meals, and found responses to identical meals varied widely from person to person.1 Their computer model, fed with blood tests, habits, body measurements and gut microbes, could predict an individual's response, and personal diets built on it lowered blood sugar after meals in a controlled trial.

The UK's PREDICT study then gave 1,002 twins and unrelated adults standard meals. Responses varied by around two-thirds of the average for blood sugar, and by more than the average itself for blood fats.2 It also gives a useful sense of proportion. For blood sugar, what was in the meal still mattered most among the factors it measured, at 15% of the variation, against 6% for personal factors such as the gut microbiome, and genes added 9.5%. For blood fats, those personal factors outweighed the meal's make-up. So what you eat counts, and your microbes shape how it lands. This is a partnership, not a verdict.

Bread gives the neatest illustration. When Israeli researchers compared a week of traditional wholegrain sourdough with a week of industrial white bread, the average results looked the same on the markers they measured. That average hid the real finding. Each person responded in their own way, and which bread suited them could be predicted from their microbes before they took a bite.3 In Sweden, barley bread improved glucose control in some healthy people and barely touched others, and the responders had more Prevotella copri. Microbes from the responders, transferred to germ-free mice, carried the improvement with them.4

Food is only half the story. The other half is who is there to receive it.

Compounds that wait for a microbe

Many of the plant compounds we prize are not fully active as we swallow them. They are raw material, and the finishing work happens in the gut.

  • Soy and equol. Soy's isoflavone daidzein can be converted by certain bacteria into equol, a compound made by bacteria rather than by our own cells, which binds to oestrogen receptors. Studies of soy have seen their strongest results in good equol producers, which may explain why soy has given such uneven results.5 Around half of adults in East Asia produce it, compared with roughly a quarter in the West.6 (See The Second Spring.)
  • Pomegranate, walnuts and urolithins. These foods, along with strawberries and raspberries, contain ellagitannins, which microbes break down into urolithins. People fall into three clear groups: those who make only urolithin A, those who also make other forms, and those in whom these end products cannot be detected at all. That last group runs at 5 to 25% of volunteers across trials.7 (For what urolithin A does for mitochondria, see A Natural Age.)
  • Broccoli and sulphoraphane. Once cooking has destroyed broccoli's own enzyme, gut bacteria can take over its job. Given a dose of broccoli sprout extract, people converted anywhere from about 1% to more than 40%, yet each person's own results were much more consistent from one test to the next.8 (See The Broccoli Trick.)
  • Red meat and TMAO. The same machinery can work against us. When regular meat eaters and vegans or vegetarians were given the same labelled dose of carnitine, a nutrient abundant in red meat, the meat eaters made more than twenty times as much TMAO from it, a compound linked with hardened arteries.9 The habitual diet had shaped the microbes. (See Meat, Reconsidered.)

Medicines pass through the same crowd. When 271 oral drugs were tested against 76 human gut bacteria, many were chemically altered, which helps to explain why the same prescription can act differently in different people.10 It is a good reason never to assume a dose behaves identically in everyone, and an equally good reason to leave any changes to your prescriber. (See The Master Regulator.)

Why the headlines keep contradicting each other

All this may explain why research on foods so often seems to go round in circles. Pomegranate is a good example: its effect on cholesterol has been disputed for years. Then a Spanish double-blind trial sorted its 49 overweight participants by urolithin group before reading the results. With the higher dose of pomegranate extract, total cholesterol fell by about 15%, LDL by a similar amount and oxidised LDL by 24%, but only in those who produced the broader range of urolithins, a group who also had the highest cardiovascular risk at the start.11 Pool everybody together and a clear effect in part of the room is diluted into a shrug.

This is what lies behind a good deal of nutritional confusion. A food can be powerful for the person whose gut is ready for it and appear to do little for the next person, and a study average may conceal both. When a trial finds a modest average effect from a plant, it may be telling us as much about the variety of human microbes as about the plant.

This capacity is not fixed

Here is the most hopeful part. Your microbes are not a birthmark. They are a living population, and what they can do shifts with time and with how you live.

  • Function can change. In a Japanese study following 498 adults yearly for four years, about 26% made equol in some years and not in others. The steady producers had a more diverse gut community, despite eating similar amounts of the soy compound as everyone else.6 In the pomegranate trial, three of the six participants who started as non-producers became producers while taking it.11
  • Age plays a part. In a study of 839 people aged 5 to 90, age was the main factor shaping urolithin groups.12 Our inner chemistry moves with us through life.
  • Microbes can learn new skills. The genes for digesting the seaweed nori's unusual carbohydrate turn up frequently in the gut bacteria of Japanese people, yet are absent from data on North Americans. They appear to have been picked up from marine bacteria on seaweed.13 A national food culture has written itself into the gut.
  • Skills can be lost. When people from south-east Asia moved to the United States, their gut diversity and function began to fall immediately, and the loss deepened with years of residence and across generations.14 In mice carrying human microbes, a low-fibre diet caused losses that were largely reversible at first, but over several generations became permanent even when fibre returned.15

Why 30 plants a week matters

The usual argument for variety is about vitamins and fibre, and that argument is sound. The microbial argument goes deeper. Each plant brings its own compounds, and each compound is worked on by particular microbes. Seen this way, a varied diet keeps a wider set of skills alive within you: a library of chemistry rather than one well-thumbed book.

In the American Gut Project, people eating more than 30 different plants a week had more varied gut microbes than those eating 10 or fewer.16 Diversity also gives resilience: in a French study where 19 adults changed their fibre intake, those with a richer gut community held more stable through the change.17

Building your inner chemistry

  • Count to 30. Vegetables, fruit, beans, whole grains, nuts, seeds, herbs and spices all count. A spoonful of mixed seeds or a handful of fresh herbs moves the number quickly.
  • Buy one new thing each week. Try a different bean, a different leaf or a less familiar grain. Each new plant brings new raw material.
  • Eat the raw material. Walnuts, berries and pomegranate for urolithins; edamame and tempeh for equol, if soy suits you; broccoli and its cousins for sulphoraphane.
  • Feed them daily. Fibre from oats, beans, lentils, onions, leeks and garlic keeps a richer community going.
  • Protect what you have. Antibiotics save lives and are often essential. Nourishing your terrain, with fibre, plants, sleep and time outdoors, makes it less likely that you will need them.
  • Give a food a fair trial. A food that disagrees with you or doesn't seem to help isn't necessarily a failure. Your response is information, and it can change as your gut changes.

In short

  • Identical meals produce widely different effects from one person to another, including in blood sugar and blood fats.
  • Gut microbes turn food compounds into active ones such as equol and urolithins, and not everyone has the right microbes at the right moment.
  • This helps explain why studies of the same food so often seem to disagree.
  • Microbial capacity can change with diet, age and environment, in both directions.
  • Eating 30 plants a week feeds a more diverse community, and with it a wider range of chemical skills.

At Rootwise, this is why we never hand out one diet for everyone. If you would like to understand how your own body responds to what you eat, and how to build the gut that makes the most of it, we can look at this together in a consultation.

References

  1. Zeevi D et al. Personalized nutrition by prediction of glycemic responses. Cell, 2015.
  2. Berry SE et al. Human postprandial responses to food and potential for precision nutrition. Nature Medicine, 2020.
  3. Korem T et al. Bread affects clinical parameters and induces gut microbiome-associated personal glycemic responses. Cell Metabolism, 2017.
  4. Kovatcheva-Datchary P et al. Dietary fiber-induced improvement in glucose metabolism is associated with increased abundance of Prevotella. Cell Metabolism, 2015.
  5. Setchell KDR, Brown NM, Lydeking-Olsen E. The clinical importance of the metabolite equol: a clue to the effectiveness of soy and its isoflavones. Journal of Nutrition, 2002.
  6. Iino K et al. Stability of equol production capability is associated with the diversity of the gut microbiota of the host: a prospective cohort study. BMC Microbiology, 2026.
  7. Tomás-Barberán FA et al. Ellagic acid metabolism by human gut microbiota: consistent observation of three urolithin phenotypes in intervention trials, independent of food source, age, and health status. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2014.
  8. Fahey JW et al. Protection of humans by plant glucosinolates: efficiency of conversion of glucosinolates to isothiocyanates by the gastrointestinal microflora. Cancer Prevention Research, 2012.
  9. Koeth RA et al. L-carnitine in omnivorous diets induces an atherogenic gut microbial pathway in humans. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 2019.
  10. Zimmermann M et al. Mapping human microbiome drug metabolism by gut bacteria and their genes. Nature, 2019.
  11. González-Sarrías A et al. Clustering according to urolithin metabotype explains the interindividual variability in the improvement of cardiovascular risk biomarkers in overweight-obese individuals consuming pomegranate: a randomized clinical trial. Molecular Nutrition & Food Research, 2017.
  12. Cortés-Martín A et al. The gut microbiota urolithin metabotypes revisited: the human metabolism of ellagic acid is mainly determined by aging. Food & Function, 2018.
  13. Hehemann JH et al. Transfer of carbohydrate-active enzymes from marine bacteria to Japanese gut microbiota. Nature, 2010.
  14. Vangay P et al. US immigration westernizes the human gut microbiome. Cell, 2018.
  15. Sonnenburg ED et al. Diet-induced extinctions in the gut microbiota compound over generations. Nature, 2016.
  16. McDonald D et al. American Gut: an open platform for citizen science microbiome research. mSystems, 2018.
  17. Tap J et al. Gut microbiota richness promotes its stability upon increased dietary fibre intake in healthy adults. Environmental Microbiology, 2015.

This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for personal advice. Never stop or change a prescribed medicine without speaking to your prescriber. If you take prescribed medicines, check supplements or large changes in your diet with your GP or pharmacist.

Your food, your microbes

A personal look at your digestion, your diet and how your body responds to food, so that what you eat can do its best work for you.