← All articles Worth It or Not?

An Old Friend in Flannel

Castor oil packs are a long-standing naturopathic treatment now finding a new audience. Are they worth it?

7 minute read

Every few years, social media discovers something that naturopaths have been doing all along. The latest is the castor oil pack: a flannel soaked in thick, pale oil, laid over the abdomen and left to work while you rest. Online, it's now said to do almost everything. In the treatment room, it has long been something quieter and more modest: a slow, soothing hour that many clients come to love. So what can we honestly say about this old friend?

A very long history

Ricinus communis, the castor plant, has been used for an astonishingly long time. Its first known written mention comes in Egypt's Ebers papyrus, from about 1550 BCE. The Greek physician Dioscorides used it in plasters for the skin, and the Roman writer Pliny recorded external use for joints, burns and itching. In Europe it was revived by Peter Canvane's treatise of 1764 and entered the London Pharmacopoeia in 1788.1 Its old name, Palma Christi, the palm of Christ, tells you the regard it was held in.

The pack as we know it was popularised in North America by the American healer Edgar Cayce, who recommended placing it over the liver and under the right ribs, and it was then carried forward in naturopathic practice and by physicians such as William McGarey. Naturopaths and herbalists continue to use packs today, often over the liver or the lower abdomen, as part of a wider plan to support digestion, elimination and rest.

What the research shows

Very little research exists on the packs themselves. Pharmaceutical companies have no reason to fund trials of a bottle of oil and a piece of flannel, so we should read this as "little studied", not "disproven". Here's what we did find.

  • Immune cells. The most-quoted study gave 36 healthy volunteers one two-hour pack of either castor oil or paraffin. Comparing the groups directly showed no significant differences, which the author put down to the participants' good health. Within the castor oil group, lymphocytes rose, peaking at about seven hours and returning to normal by 24.2 That's a striking response to a single two-hour pack.
  • Constipation. In a small study of older people in Turkish rest homes, three days of packs didn't change how often they went, but stools were softer, with less straining and a better sense of having finished.3 For frail older people, that's a gentle, external help worth knowing.
  • Inflammation. In animal studies, ricinoleic acid, the main fatty acid in castor oil, increased swelling after one application to the skin, but reduced it with eight days of repeated use, along with lower levels of the pain messenger substance P.4 That pattern sits well with the tradition of regular, repeated packs.
  • Swallowed castor oil. This is a different matter, and better understood. Ricinoleic acid acts on EP3 receptors on the smooth muscle of the gut and uterus, which explains the famous laxative effect.5 In a trial of 100 people with knee osteoarthritis, capsules did as well as the medicine diclofenac.6

Little studied is not the same as disproven.

What the pack can certainly offer

Alongside the oil, the ritual has value of its own. You're lying down, warm and still, with a hand or a flannel resting over your belly. That's not nothing. Digestion belongs to the rest-and-digest side of the nervous system, and many people are rarely on that side at all. Warmth over the abdomen, an unhurried hour and permission to stop do useful work in their own right, and it's the kind of thing a capsule trial would never capture. Calm isn't a side effect here: it's part of the treatment.

How it's traditionally used

Use a clean piece of cotton or wool flannel, moistened but not dripping with cold-pressed castor oil. Lay it over the area, usually the right upper abdomen or the lower belly, and cover it with an old towel, since castor oil stains everything it touches. A hot water bottle or heat pad on top is traditional, on a setting you can comfortably bear. Rest for about an hour, then wash the skin. Practices vary between practitioners, and how often to use it is a personal question, so a qualified practitioner can guide you on what suits your constitution and your situation.

Safety

  • Pregnancy. Swallowed castor oil has long been used to bring on labour, and it acts on the uterus.5,7,8 Women taking it commonly reported nausea. We know of no studies of packs in pregnancy, but because of this action, we'd say avoid them if you're pregnant or may be, and take advice if you're trying to conceive.
  • Skin. Testing shows that castor oil is not a significant irritant for most people, but reactions do happen, and they're more likely if you have an existing skin condition.9 Try a small patch first, and don't use a pack on broken or inflamed skin.
  • Other chemicals. Castor oil can help other substances pass through the skin,9 so use a clean, plain oil and don't mix it with fragranced products.
  • Ricin. The seeds contain the deadly toxin ricin, which often alarms people. It doesn't pass into the oil.9 The seeds themselves are dangerous, though, so never use them.
  • Heat. Take care with heat pads, particularly if you have reduced feeling or might fall asleep.

If you have a bowel condition, unexplained abdominal pain, or a known liver or gallbladder problem, or you're having medical treatment, please seek further advice first. A pack is a form of support; it doesn't replace getting a new or persistent symptom looked at.

A word on the online claims

You'll find packs promoted online for dissolving cysts, flushing toxins and melting fibroids. It would be wrong to rely on a pack for these. A long tradition of gentle use is a fine reason to try something. It's not a reason to delay finding out what's causing a problem.

Worth it or not? Our verdict

  • Worth trying, for most adults who aren't pregnant, as a low-cost traditional practice and a restful hour.
  • A long-standing naturopathic treatment, still recommended, and little studied rather than disproven.
  • Encouraging signals for constipation in older people and for immune cells.
  • Avoid in pregnancy, and patch test first.
  • Be wary of grand claims. It's a gentle support, not a cure for cysts or fibroids.

At Rootwise, we value traditional practices for what they offer: time, warmth, attention and the chance to help your body from the outside. If you'd like to know whether a castor oil pack belongs in your plan, and what else might, a consultation is a good place to begin.

References

  1. Touwaide A. Herbs in history: Ricinus. American Herbal Products Association, ahpa.org, 2024.
  2. Grady H. Immunomodulation through castor oil packs. Journal of Naturopathic Medicine, vol 7(1).
  3. Arslan GG, Eşer I. An examination of the effect of castor oil packs on constipation in the elderly. Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice, 2011.
  4. Vieira C et al. Effect of ricinoleic acid in acute and subchronic experimental models of inflammation. Mediators of Inflammation, 2000.
  5. Tunaru S et al. Castor oil induces laxation and uterus contraction via ricinoleic acid activating prostaglandin EP3 receptors. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2012.
  6. Medhi B et al. Comparative clinical trial of castor oil and diclofenac sodium in patients with osteoarthritis. Phytotherapy Research, 2009.
  7. Kelly AJ et al. Castor oil, bath and/or enema for cervical priming and induction of labour. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2013.
  8. Amerizadeh A et al. Effect and safety of castor oil on labor induction and prevalence of vaginal delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Iranian Journal of Nursing and Midwifery Research, 2022.
  9. Cosmetic Ingredient Review Expert Panel. Final report on the safety assessment of Ricinus communis (castor) seed oil and related ingredients. International Journal of Toxicology, 2007.

This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for personal advice. If you take prescribed medicines, check any herbs or supplements with your GP or pharmacist, and never stop or change a prescribed medicine without your prescriber.

Traditional care, personally chosen

A whole-person consultation that brings traditional naturopathic practices together with your diet, your history and modern testing.