Every culture on Earth has its healers, and every one of them heals through more than chemistry. There's the remedy, and there's also the setting, the words, the touch, the shared story about what is wrong and what will put it right. Modern medicine has spent a century trying to strip that second part away so that it can measure the first. Anthropologists, who study healing across the world's cultures, have spent the same century showing how much the second part matters.
The same pill, a different country
In the 1980s and 1990s, the American anthropologist Daniel Moerman looked closely at the placebo groups in 117 trials of stomach ulcer drugs from 32 countries. Ulcers are a useful test, because healing is checked by looking directly at the stomach lining. It isn't a matter of how someone feels.
The results were astonishing. On average, around 37% of ulcers healed on a dummy pill. In six German studies, 59% healed. In three Brazilian studies, just 7% did. Germany's close neighbours, the Netherlands and Denmark, came in at 22%.1,2 The same inert tablet, given for the same condition, was eight times as effective in one country as in another.
Stranger still, German placebo groups did worse than average in trials for high blood pressure.2 So this isn't about some nations being more "suggestible". Each culture carries its own beliefs about particular organs and particular illnesses, and the body seems to listen to them.
The body listens to the story a culture tells about it.
Meaning, more than belief
Moerman argued that "placebo effect" is the wrong name. A sugar pill does nothing by itself, so he proposed calling it the meaning response: the real, physical effects of what an illness and a treatment mean to the person receiving it.3 The colour of a pill, its price, the confidence of the person giving it, a needle rather than a tablet, a diagnosis that finally makes sense of years of symptoms: all of these carry meaning, and all of them have been shown to change results.
This is subtler than "you have to believe in it". People with irritable bowel syndrome improved on pills they were openly told were placebos, as we explore in The Belief Effect. Something in the ritual of care, the attention and the act of taking a remedy each day, does its own quiet work, even when the mind is sceptical.
The healer's song
In 1949, the French anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss wrote about a long healing chant used by the Guna people of Panama during a difficult childbirth. The shaman doesn't touch the mother. Instead, the song takes her on a journey through her own body, naming its places, its pains and the spirit holding back the birth, until the struggle is won. Lévi-Strauss saw that the chant gave her a language for an experience that had none, and that once pain had a shape and a story, the body could reorganise itself around it.4
The Harvard psychiatrist and anthropologist Arthur Kleinman later named the distinction at the heart of this. Disease is what a doctor measures: the faulty valve, the inflamed tissue. Illness is what a person lives through: the fear, the disruption, the meaning of it all.5 Traditional healers almost always work on illness. Modern medicine is superb with disease. The person who is suffering needs both.
When meaning harms
Meaning can wound as well as heal. In 1942, Walter Cannon, the Harvard physiologist who gave us the phrase "fight or flight", gathered accounts from around the world of people who sickened and died within days of being cursed, or of breaking a powerful taboo, with no injury or poison to explain it.6 He proposed that intense fear, along with the withdrawal of the whole community, could drive the nervous system into collapse.
Modern medicine has its own quieter curses. A grim prognosis delivered without care, or a long list of side effects read aloud, can bring on exactly the symptoms it describes. Researchers call it the nocebo effect, and it's a reminder that words in a clinic are never neutral.
The plants were never the placebo
None of this means traditional remedies work "only" through belief. Plants carry real chemistry, and the healers who used them were often highly skilled observers. Of 122 plant compounds used as medicines worldwide, around 80% are used for the same or related purposes that the source plant served in traditional medicine.7 Healers had found them first.
In the 1970s, the Chinese scientist Tu Youyou was searching for a malaria treatment. Her team's extracts of sweet wormwood kept failing, until she found a recipe in a handbook written around 1,700 years ago by the physician Ge Hong. It said to soak the herb in cold water, not to boil it. She realised that heat might be destroying the active compound, switched to a gentle low-temperature extraction, and found artemisinin. It has since saved millions of lives, and in 2015 it won her the Nobel Prize. She called it "a gift from traditional Chinese medicine to the world".8 Even aspirin owes its name to a herb: the "spir" comes from Spiraea ulmaria, the old botanical name for meadowsweet, from which salicylic acid was first isolated in the 1830s.9
Herbs work best when matched to the person, though, not just to the complaint. A remedy that suits one constitution may not suit another, which is why we encourage working with a practitioner rather than self-prescribing. See The Architecture of Balance.
Why an outsider may not feel the same
So what happens when a Westerner travels to a remote healer for a few weeks? The plants bring their chemistry. But the songs, the spirits, the community gathered round and the language of cause and cure were built for people raised inside that culture, and they may mean far less to a visitor. Half of the medicine, the meaning half, may simply not have anything to work on. That isn't proof that the medicine is "hocus pocus". It's a sign of how deeply healing is woven into culture, and it's a fair question to ask whenever a traditional remedy is judged by how outsiders respond to it.
It cuts both ways. Modern medicine's own rituals, the white coat, the scan, the prescription, carry enormous meaning in our culture, and they draw on the meaning response too.
Letting meaning work for you
- Choose healers you trust, who take time to listen and explain. Being heard is part of the medicine.
- Make your remedies a ritual. Brew the tea yourself, sit down to drink it, and give it a moment of attention.
- Understand your plan. Knowing why each step is there turns instructions into something that makes sense to you.
- Notice the stories you tell about your body and your illness, and look for the ones that leave room for recovery. See Not Written in Stone.
- Honour your own traditions, family remedies and practices that carry meaning for you.
One caution matters. Meaning is a powerful ally, but it is never anyone's fault if they don't recover. Serious illness can outrun any medicine, ancient or modern, and no one should ever be told they simply didn't believe enough.
In short
- The same placebo healed ulcers in 59% of German patients and 7% of Brazilian ones.
- Anthropologists call it the meaning response: illness and treatment carry meanings that the body responds to.
- Healing has two sides: the disease that can be measured, and the illness that is lived.
- Most plant-derived medicines were first used for the same purpose by traditional healers.
- Remedies from another culture may lose their meaning half when given to outsiders.
At Rootwise, we see the plants, the person and the meaning as one picture. A consultation gives time to understand what your health means to you, so that your plan makes sense in your life and every part of it pulls in the same direction.
References
- Moerman DE. General medical effectiveness and human biology: placebo effects in the treatment of ulcer disease. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 1983.
- Moerman DE. Cultural variations in the placebo effect: ulcers, anxiety, and blood pressure. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 2000.
- Moerman DE, Jonas WB. Deconstructing the placebo effect and finding the meaning response. Annals of Internal Medicine, 2002.
- Lévi-Strauss C. The effectiveness of symbols. In Structural Anthropology, 1963 (first published in French, 1949).
- Kleinman A. Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture. University of California Press, 1980.
- Cannon WB. "Voodoo" death. American Anthropologist, 1942.
- Fabricant DS, Farnsworth NR. The value of plants used in traditional medicine for drug discovery. Environmental Health Perspectives, 2001.
- Tu Y. Discovery of artemisinin: a gift from traditional Chinese medicine to the world. Nobel Lecture, 2015.
- Jeffreys D. Aspirin: The Remarkable Story of a Wonder Drug. Bloomsbury, 2004.
This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for personal advice. If you take prescribed medicines, check any herbs or supplements with your GP or pharmacist, and never stop or change a prescribed medicine without your prescriber.